Should murdering service members be punishable by death?
Rep. Tim Murphy of Pennsylvania wants to make murdering a service member a federal crime punishable by death. The “Captain Scott Corwin Armed Forces Protection Act” would treat the murder, attempted murder or conspiracy to murder a member of the military the same as killing or trying to kill a law enforcement officer. Right now, it’s only a federal crime if the accused knows the victim is a service member. The law would apply even if the service member is out of uniform or in a place where it’s not clear he or she is in the military, the same as undercover police.
Army Capt. Scott Corwin
The bill stems from the 2004 shooting death of Darien Illinois native Army Captain Scott Corwin. The Hinsdale South High School grad was killed in Savannah, Georgia while he and his girlfriend were walking near a downtown square. His shooting is still unsolved. Click on Corwin's picture to get more information about the foundation his family has set up.
There’s no doubt, this country owes a huge debt of gratitude to the service men and women who put their lives on the line to protect this country and the lifestyle we’ve grown accustomed to. Given the state of the world today and dangers they face while serving, especially in Iraq and Afghanistan, saying “thank you” is not always enough. Sometimes, especially now that there’s this huge debate about whether to bring the troops home, people want to go out of their way to make sure military members get the utmost respect. After all, they deserve it. But is this proposed law fair? It says, even if you don’t know this person is a service member, you will still be punished. At least with undercover police, they are protecting and serving (we hope). If the service members are out of uniform, in a place that doesn’t obviously identify them as a service member, then aren’t they just like the rest of us, trying to enjoy life?


Tonya Francisco joined CLTV in December of 2002, she can be seen each weekday morning anchoring the CLTV Morning News.
Sean Lewis is CLTV's midday anchor. You can catch him every weekday between 11 a.m. and 5 p.m.
Monica Schneider is CLTV's weekend evening news anchor and is a general assignment reporter.
Judy Wang is the anchor of the CLTV weekend morning news and reports general assignment stories during the week.
Carlos Hernandez Gomez covers local, statewide and national politics, as well as legal affairs and the courts.
Randi Belisomo joined CLTV as a general assignment reporter in 2006.
Regina Waldroup joined CLTV as an Anchor/ Reporter in August 2006.
Aaron Baskerville joined CLTV as an anchor/ reporter in September 2007.
Lou Canellis is the host for CLTV's Sunday night sports program, "Sports Page".